How to Compare the Annual Cost of Two Used Cars in Canada
A CAD worksheet for estimating fuel and annual insurance costs for two used cars, with formulas, a fictional example and guidance on comparing annual expenses without confusing them with the purchase price.
Key points
Compare two used cars in Canada by calculating fuel costs as annual kilometres × L/100 km ÷ 100, multiplied by the local price in CAD/L. Add a real annual insurance quote and other documented expenses for each car; the numerical example is fictional.
Start with four figures for each car
To compare the annual costs of two used cars, estimate fuel and insurance separately. You’ll need annual kilometres, the car’s actual or documented fuel consumption in L/100 km, the local fuel price in CAD/L, and an annual insurance quote for each vehicle. You can then add other known annual expenses, such as maintenance or parking.
Record the date and source for each figure. Use consumption data for the car’s exact year and version; figures for another engine or version could skew the result. In Prince George, enter the local price you expect to pay, not a generic Canadian price. Don’t mix L/100 km with miles per gallon or litres-equivalent figures: this formula requires fuel consumption in L/100 km.
- Kilometres driven per year (km/year).
- Fuel consumption for the car’s year and version (L/100 km).
- Local fuel price and date (CAD/L).
- A real annual insurance quote for each car (CAD/year).
- Other annual expenses, only if you have a documented figure.
Fuel formulas and a fictional example
Annual fuel consumption (L) = km/year × consumption (L/100 km) ÷ 100. Annual fuel cost (CAD) = litres per year × fuel price (CAD/L). The units work out as follows: km/year × L/100 km gives L/year; multiplying by CAD/L gives CAD/year.
Entirely fictional example, dated November 16, 2026. The figures below are invented assumptions for demonstrating the arithmetic; they are not current prices, consumption figures for real models, average rates, quotes or offers. At 12,000 km/year and CAD 1.80/L, Car A, assumed to consume 7 L/100 km, uses 12,000 × 7 ÷ 100 = 840 L/year and costs 840 × 1.80 = CAD 1,512/year in fuel. Car B, assumed to consume 9 L/100 km, uses 12,000 × 9 ÷ 100 = 1,080 L/year and costs 1,080 × 1.80 = CAD 1,944/year.
If you add also-fictional premiums of CAD 1,400/year for A and CAD 1,600/year for B, fuel plus insurance totals CAD 2,912/year for A and CAD 3,544/year for B—a difference of CAD 632/year. This is not a personalised estimate. Replace all these assumptions with your own figures and quotes.
| Figure or result | Car A (assumption) | Car B (assumption) |
|---|---|---|
| Kilometres per year | 12,000 km | 12,000 km |
| Fuel consumption | 7 L/100 km | 9 L/100 km |
| Fuel price | CAD 1.80/L | CAD 1.80/L |
| Calculated fuel cost | 840 L/year × 1.80 = CAD 1,512/year | 1,080 L/year × 1.80 = CAD 1,944/year |
| Assumed annual insurance | CAD 1,400/year | CAD 1,600/year |
| Fuel + insurance | CAD 2,912/year | CAD 3,544/year |
Copyable spreadsheet template
Copy the table and replace the blank entries with information for your two cars. Input cells are figures you provide; results are calculated using the formulas shown. The table is not an interactive calculator or a downloadable file. Keep the date and source for every figure so you can review the comparison.
| Figure (input unless noted) | Car A | Car B |
|---|---|---|
| Year and version | [enter] | [enter] |
| Kilometres driven per year (km/year) | [enter] | [enter] |
| Fuel consumption (L/100 km) | [enter] | [enter] |
| Consumption source and date | [enter] | [enter] |
| Local fuel price (CAD/L) and date | [enter] | [enter] |
| Litres per year (result) | km/year × L/100 km ÷ 100 | km/year × L/100 km ÷ 100 |
| Fuel cost (CAD/year, result) | litres/year × CAD/L | litres/year × CAD/L |
| Quoted annual insurance (CAD/year) | [enter real quote] | [enter real quote] |
| Insurer, quote date and validity | [enter] | [enter] |
| Documented annual maintenance (CAD/year) | [enter or leave blank] | [enter or leave blank] |
| Registration, fees, parking and other costs (CAD/year) | [enter applicable items] | [enter applicable items] |
| Annual total of included expenses (CAD/year, result) | fuel + insurance + other annual expenses | fuel + insurance + other annual expenses |
Comparing insurance in British Columbia
Use a real annual quote for each car, based on the same driver or drivers, location, vehicle use, coverage and deductible, and record when the quote is valid. This makes it easier to compare the cars rather than differences in quote conditions. You don’t need to include personal details in your comparison sheet; keep only the amounts and conditions needed for a fair comparison.
ICBC says that factors affecting insurance in British Columbia include where you live, how you use the vehicle, coverage level, the vehicle, the deductible, and drivers’ experience and crash history. A reliable premium can’t be worked out from the make or model alone, and a national average isn’t a quote. These ICBC insurance factors apply to British Columbia and shouldn’t be assumed to be rules for all of Canada.
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada also recommends requesting and comparing quotes. It notes that the vehicle, its use, driving history, coverage and deductible can affect premiums. Use the quote you receive, including its terms and validity period, in your comparison.
Section references: What determines insurance costs? ↗ · What to know about buying insurance ↗ · Car insurance ↗
Add other expenses without double-counting
You can add maintenance, registration or fees, and parking when they apply, using figures documented for your situation. Separate recurring expenses from one-time payments; don’t count a one-time cost as if it recurred every year. Use the same comparison period for both cars.
The template’s total is a subtotal of the expenses you’ve included, not necessarily the full cost of ownership. Total cost of ownership can include depreciation—the loss in value over a period. If you calculate depreciation, don’t also count the full purchase price, loan instalments or loan principal as equivalent expenses. First define what you’re measuring: annual running costs or total cost of ownership.
What affects the result and a related tool
The annual difference depends on the figures you enter. Driving more kilometres increases the calculated fuel expense; a change in the price per litre changes each car’s cost based on its estimated fuel use. A different insurance quote can also change which car costs less. If the result is close, carefully check the kilometres, consumption for the exact version, dated local fuel price and equivalent insurance terms.
The annual vehicle cost tool can complement this comparison with an estimate in euros that includes straight-line depreciation and the annual expenses you enter. Its inputs are in EUR and it doesn’t calculate insurance premiums. Don’t enter CAD amounts as if they were EUR or use it instead of this CAD comparison worksheet.
Section references: Annual vehicle ownership cost calculator ↗
What information do I need to calculate annual fuel costs?
You need annual kilometres, fuel consumption for the exact year and version in L/100 km, and the local fuel price in CAD/L with its date. Calculate km/year × L/100 km ÷ 100 to get litres per year, then multiply by CAD/L.
Can I use an average insurance premium to estimate the cost for each car?
For a useful comparison, use a real annual quote for each car based on equivalent conditions. In British Columbia, ICBC considers factors including the driver, driving history, location, vehicle use, vehicle, coverage and deductible. An average isn’t a personal quote.
Does the template also calculate depreciation and total cost of ownership?
No. It adds fuel, insurance and any other annual expenses you enter. Depreciation requires a separate calculation; define the period and avoid counting the full purchase price, loan principal and depreciation simultaneously as if they were the same expense.


